The +1 Method · chapter 9: Becoming a Gym Goer

The identity crossover

2026-11-19

The reps grow one a day, so their cost rises slowly. The cost of deciding falls much faster, and once it falls below the reps, showing up stops feeling like a choice. This is a drawing of how it felt, not measured data, and the crossing has no fixed date: Lally and colleagues modelled times to automaticity anywhere from 18 to 254 days, exercise took the longest of the behaviours they studied, and about half their participants never reached the plateau at all inside the study.

Below: the paragraph from the book that builds this idea, then the diagram itself (Figure 9.1), and a recap. About a minute of reading.

Here is the part I did not expect. Two different efforts are running at the same time, and they move in opposite directions. The reps get harder, slowly, one more every day. The deciding gets easier, and it gets easier much faster. On day 3 the reps take twenty seconds and the argument with myself takes twenty minutes. On day 90 the reps take a few minutes and the argument does not happen, because there is nothing left to argue about. Somewhere between those two days the lines cross, and the hard part of the habit stops being whether and starts being just doing. Figure 9.1 draws the two lines.

Figure 9.1: The identity crossover. The reps grow one a day, so their cost rises slowly. The cost of deciding falls much faster, and once it falls below the reps, showing up stops feeling like a choice. This is a drawing of how it felt, not measured data, and the crossing has no fixed date: Lally and colleagues modelled times to automaticity anywhere from 18 to 254 days, exercise took the longest of the behaviours they studied, and about half their participants never reached the plateau at all inside the study.
Figure 9.1: The identity crossover. The reps grow one a day, so their cost rises slowly. The cost of deciding falls much faster, and once it falls below the reps, showing up stops feeling like a choice. This is a drawing of how it felt, not measured data, and the crossing has no fixed date: Lally and colleagues modelled times to automaticity anywhere from 18 to 254 days, exercise took the longest of the behaviours they studied, and about half their participants never reached the plateau at all inside the study.
Use this diagram on your site

Free to share in your blog post, docs, course or slides, as long as the credit link stays. Paste the code below where the figure should go.

Recap

  • The idea: The reps grow one a day, so their cost rises slowly.
  • The picture: Figure 9.1, from chapter 9 ("Becoming a Gym Goer") of The +1 Method.
  • Go deeper: the chapter builds this step by step, with recipes and sources at the end.

This diagram is one of many in The +1 Method.

Every chapter opens with the gist, draws the hard ideas, and ends with recipes and sources.

Get the book

All diagrams